Trump Falls into the US Neocon / BRICS laid Thucydides Trap

 

from Google AI:

The Thucydides Trap, coined by Graham Allison, describes the high risk of war when a rising power threatens to displace a ruling power, a concept derived from Sparta’s fear of a rising Athens in ancient Greece. Historical studies indicate that in 12 of 16 cases over the past 500 years, such structural stress resulted in conflict, not peace.

Key Elements and Context 

The Origin: The phrase stems from Athenian historian Thucydides, who wrote that "It was the rise of Athens and the fear that this instilled in Sparta that made war inevitable".

Modern Application: The theory is primarily applied to the current tension between the United States (ruling) and China (rising)
.
Key Drivers: Conflict arises from structural pressures rather than immediate provocation, where the dominant power fears losing its position, and the rising power feels entitled to more influence.

Potential Consequences and Criticism 

Consequences: If not managed, the trap can escalate trade disputes, proxy wars, or minor accidents into full-scale, devastating war.

Criticisms: Critics argue the theory is overly deterministic, ignoring human agency, diplomacy, and the inhibiting factor of nuclear deterrence. Some argue the historical cases are not directly comparable to modern Sino-US relations due to high economic interdependence.

Avoiding the Trap 

The trap is not inevitable; Allison notes that 4 of the 16 historical cases did not lead to war. Avoiding it requires conscious efforts from leaders to:

Manage Rivalry: Engage in competition without resorting to violence.

Establish New Systems: Develop new international relations frameworks (similar to China’s "new type of international relations" goal).

Recognize Miscalculations: Avoid the misinterpretations that characterized the Peloponnesian War, as highlighted in studies on the Thucydides Trap File.