Thursday, October 24, 2024

Time to Change the Guard in Ukraine?

Joseph Kulve, "Ukraine Needs A Milei -- and May Have Found One"
A year ago, Ukrainians were mocking Russia for forcing poorly trained and armed men into battle. Russia was supposedly running out of men and money.

In central Kyiv (I was there) the government displayed large maps of how Russia might fragment after its impending defeat. Victory was certain, as were the Western handouts to the future victor.

But lately the Ukrainian language blogosphere has been talking openly about Ukrainian front-line soldiers who do not have the weapons they need to fight (drones, 155m shells, guns, ammo, everything). Many are deserting. There is open talk about Russia winning.

We (the collective West) would not have been surprised by all of this if we had really understood the Ukrainian government and the people.

Understanding them now is critical, because as things fall apart, things might get a lot crazier (especially if President Trump loses the vote count).

The Ukraine government is demanding American missiles for hitting targets deep in Russia. They justify their new demands by claiming that America’s refusal to meet their previous demands (financial and military) is why they are losing the war.

Call it the Ukrainian peace plan scam.

Fast forward to Pavlo Sebastianovich, a Ukrainian entrepreneur who became a blogger, who says that only a drastic reduction of an unreformable criminal Ukrainian government can save Ukraine.

His core ideas are very much like those of Argentina's radical libertarian president, Javier Milei (Sebastianovich recently posted a YouTube video of Milei’s speech to the U.N.)

Pavlo’s audience are Ukrainians, but his description of the real situation in Ukraine, created in great part by the Biden-Harris regime, is a critical message that Americans are not getting.

The following is my summary of several of Pavlo’s recent video posts (he consistently focuses on the same issues). I reorganized and edited for brevity and my comments are in parentheses.

Ukraine is reducing war funding. Spending on weaponry (as shown in blue in this diagram) has shrunk (in dollars) in half from 2023 to 2025. During that same time Ukraine has increased funding for the bureaucracy, even though the population has decreased by several million (35 years ago the population was 50 million, and there are now probably less than 30 million living in Ukrainian government-controlled territory). Non-defense government spending has been increasing rapidly. Meanwhile Ukrainian government crime has skyrocketed (for example, recently $6m in bribe money was discovered in the apartment of a family of regional Ukrainian bureaucrats).

Worst of all, Zelensky’s so-called “peace plans” are a joke (and possibly deadly for America). The four demands (from Ukraine, not from the West) of the (most recent) Zelensky “peace” plan simply can not be implemented. The first demand is making Ukraine a part of the civilized world (NATO and the EU). But Soviet Ukraine meets none of the standards for NATO membership. Ukrainian tax and customs agencies alone steal $10 billion to $15 billion a year from the budget (the mafia tactics of the Ukrainian tax police and customs service are beyond the wildest imagination of Western taxpayers). Scams include fictional VAT, reduced prices during import, increased prices for export, and counterfeit products (cigarettes, alcohol, and fuel, all sold roadside). Do you really think they will let such a tax hole like Ukraine into the EU?

The second demand is giving Ukraine a lot of money. The West has been giving Ukraine $40 billion to $60 billion a year in aid. The Ukrainian national bank siphons $10 billion a year, most of that to buy gold reserves for stability of the banking system. $22 billion is spent annually on 1.5 million government workers. Higher level government officials get exorbitant (by Ukrainian standards) pay (on this chart the lowest pay is $3,300/month, in a country with a median salary of $530). The recent budget includes 10% to 75% increases for the funding of various Ukrainian non-war government ministries, even though the population has significantly decreased (by probably 10 million during the war).

Government ministries must approve grants and donations from Western organizations (for which they expect thanks later). They all have their own NGOs (ukrfreedomfund.org claims that 90% of charitable funds for Ukraine are donated to large international nonprofits, with 87% of that aid never making it near the front lines).

The third demand setting aside (a massive amount of) money for the post-war rebuilding of Ukraine would be a gold rush for Ukrainian government officials and their deputies who all have their own communal enterprises for building roads, manufacturing concrete, etc.

The fourth and final demand (the deadliest aspect of the “peace plan” for America) is giving Ukraine long range rockets to bomb Russia. Why would the Americans want to hit a nuclear power with their weapons?

Russia's leader, Vladimir Putin, knows that Americans will be entering the coordinates and pressing the launch button for these weapons!

Why doesn’t Ukraine focus on freeing up the occupied territories? Every year Budanov (the intelligence chief) claims that Russia will soon no longer have the resources to continue fighting (Google “Budanov says the war will end”).

But Bloomberg predicts a constant rise in Russian defense spending (original article), up to $140 billion in 2025 (6.2% of GDP, 35% of gov spending), almost double from the 75$ billion spent in 2022. Even so, Ukraine should with $40 billion to $60 billion be able to destroy the invaders on Ukrainian territory, since Russia must finance not just the Ukraine war, but also a submarine fleet, nuclear missiles, and many other projects.

Fact is, with this kind of spending, the Milei solution is the only solution for Ukraine (and America).

For the Ukrainian government, war means victimhood status and untracked cash. They will do all they can to support the corrupt and incompetent Biden-Harris regime because it means more illegit income. Ukraine is rabidly anti-Trump (and anti-Republican) because they know how Trump will deal with them: "I want foreign leaders to look like they just got dental work after meeting with my President, not walk away with a pallet of cash."

The unreformable leech state in America (and its high-tech partners) also knows the threat that Trump represents (with his plan to have the likes of Vivek Ramaswamy and Elon Musk do to them what Pavlo can only dream of doing in Ukraine).

The lawless border is only one racket of many for American government agencies, their NGOs, and third world crime states.

Unelected bureaucrats in the so-called department of “homeland” “security” are brazenly ignoring border laws and spending billions on border criminals (much of which undoubtedly gets kicked back). High tech is also in on these rackets (just Google this topic, and you’ll get only anti-Trump pro-FEMA links). And many of the much vaunted “American people” are partners in these crimes, either afraid to talk (in fear of losing their jobs and pensions) or simply ambivalent about the evil (as recently explained in an AT post by Olivia Murray).

The only solution is to implement what Pavlo (vainly) hopes for in Ukraine and Milei has already put in motion in Argentina: A drastic reduction in government. In a recent Ron Paul video “The Fed’s Depreciating Dollar,” Peter Schiff explains “All the (USA) government can do (to fix things) is undo the things they have done to hurt the economy … the only way the government can stimulate the economy is by making itself smaller, because government is dead weight, government is a drag on the economy.” If Trump-Vance win the vote count, America could be the next Argentina with Milei. If they lose, America will become more like Ukraine (or Argentina before Milei), with the nail in the coffin not being millions of its best citizens leaving (as in Ukraine), but millions of invading Democratic uniparty foot soldiers.

12 comments:

Rattrapper said...

Dylan Dervish Xijiping Zelensky Mulvaney Sanders just applied for a Green Card to Ukraine.

The Prophet Dervish Z Sanders said...

I doubt it.

Salvatore said...

As most of us know, the left has been trying to trample first amendment rights for a while now. They seem to believe in government censorship and the government being able to judge themselves what is information and what is “misinformation” , basically like Putin does in Russia. Where that is expected. The media IS controlled by him and he decides what is information and what is misinformation and he even arrests and jails those who are found guilty of spreading misinformation as attacks against the government, AKA treason. The following are some excerpts from the linked article detailing how democrats are trying to take democracy away.

former Secretary of State John Kerry argued that when it comes to “disinformation”, the “First Amendment stands as a major block to be able to just, you know, hammer it out of existence”.

But other activists took a different view from the ACLU. In 2018, two of the founders of Critical Race Theory, Richard Delgado and Jean Stefancic, republished their 1997 book Must We Defend Nazis?: Hate Speech, Pornography, and the New First Amendment. This version of the book was modified according to the shift in activists’ demands, and the subtitle was now Why the First Amendment Should Not Protect Hate Speech and White Supremacy. In that same year, activist and legal scholar Justin Hansford argued in the Yale Law Journal Forum that, when it comes to race, the “marketplace of ideas” does not apply. “When ideas on race that would disrupt the racial hierarchy of white over Black emerge,” wrote Hansford, “the First Amendment is disproportionately applied to trample that dissent”.

“If the Democrats are triumphant in the election, Americans will be governed by an administration that does not believe the First Amendment is fit for purpose”
So think about that when you Vote in this very important election.
DO YOU WANT TO LOSE YOUR FREEDOMS?

Joe Conservative said...

The Left is dumber than a sack of hammers, but they're desperate, and will do ANYTHING to win. They don't care about laws or Constitutions, just winning.

Rattrapper said...

So true, Joe. And Dervnac's been getting a political beatdown at The Donkey's Revenge.

The Prophet Dervish Z Sanders said...

Minus: The Left is dumber than a sack of hammers, but they're desperate, and will do ANYTHING to win. They don't care about laws or Constitutions, just winning.

You agree with Beamish that tяump is a Leftist?

Joe Conservative said...

Trump isn't dumb.

Joe Conservative said...

...or the Left's hammers wouldn't be in a sack.

The Prophet Dervish Z Sanders said...

d0n0ld is the dumbest man ever to be president.

Joe Conservative said...

Twice. :)

The Prophet Dervish Z Sanders said...

Was tRump secretly president right now? If so, he can't run again. I guess, if the tRump/Vance ticket "wins", then it will be president Vance who is sworn in? There is an amendment to the Constitution that says he can't serve a third term.

The Prophet Dervish Z Sanders said...

You do admit that tRump is stupid. I guess that's what you want?